TestPage2: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 11:15, 24 June 2025

Introduction[edit]

The story of the Battle of Shizugatake is often oversimplified. However, the more you dig into it, the more a fascinating game of chess unfolds across the landscape of Northern Omi. One that would put Hashiba (Toyotomi) Hideyoshi on the road to Kanpaku.

Note: Dates used below are in the old Japanese lunisolar calendar. A few modern dates have been added in parentheses at critical points for reference. This is especially important regarding the season and snowfalls for this region.

Prelude to Battle (1582–1583)[edit]

On June 27, 1582 (Aug. 2), the Council of Kiyosu was held in Owari, where the distribution of Oda Nobunaga’s territories was decided following his death at Honnō-ji. Yet this meeting failed to stabilize the political situation—it merely ignited a new power struggle to fill the void Nobunaga left behind.

One of the spoils of this reshuffling was Nagahama Castle, originally built by Hideyoshi, it was now controlled by Shibata Katsuie who placed it under the command of his adopted son Katsutoyo. It must have pained Hideyoshi to see one of his beloved castles controlled by a rival.

Hideyoshi was a tactical master. While Shibata and his allies waited for spring, he seized the initiative.

On December 2 (Jan. 11, 1583), under the cover of snowfall, Hideyoshi attacked Nagahama Castle. Katsutoyo was unable to receive reinforcements from Echizen and soon capitulated to Hideyoshi. On December 20, Hideyoshi captured Gifu Castle, forcing Oda Nobutaka to surrender. In January 1583, Takigawa Kazumasu mounted a counterattack in northern Ise against this Hideyoshi aggression. It was also quickly defeated. Toward Echizen, Hideyoshi established an outpost at Tenjinyama Fort to counter Shibata's Genbao Castle. It included satellite forts at Chausuyama Fort and Imaichikami Fort to monitor the Hokkoku Kaido and watch for any movement by Shibata.

Shibata must have been chomping at the bit. He was snowbound in Echizen and unable to open another front against Hideyoshi. Seasonal "white demon" (白魔) snows closed the mountain passes to him. Had the three parties linked up or divided Hideyoshi's attention to multiple fronts, Japanese history may have been very different.

Drawing the Battle lines[edit]

One of the earliest strategic preparations was the fortification of Genbao Castle, located on the border of Ōmi and Echizen Provinces. Genbao was notably well designed, suggesting that plans for its construction began soon after the Kiyosu Council.

By late February (late March), Shibata Katsuie made the bold decision to mobilize, despite lingering snow in the mountains. His advance force arrived at Genbao Castle on March 5th (April 10), where they began preparing it to serve as Shibata’s forward field command. When the main force followed, Sakuma Morimasa and other key generals moved to Mount Gyoichi (行市山) to establish Shibata’s primary line of defense.

What followed was the construction of one of the largest and most intricate networks of mountaintop forts and field fortifications seen during the Sengoku period for a single military conflict.

Shibata's Forward Defensive Line[edit]

Gyoichiyama Fort Sakuma Morimasa

A small stronghold atop Mt. Gyoichi, connected to Genbao Castle by a rugged 3.5km ridgeline.

Besshoyama Fort Maeda Toshiie

Roughly 1km down the steep slope from Gyoichiyama. Its broad, relatively level terrain allowed it to host a large force.

Tochidaniyama Fort Hara Nagayori

Situated 400 meters downslope from Besshoyama Fort, acting as a central hub in this line of defense.

Nakataniyama Fort Tokuyama Hideaki and Kanamori Nagachika

500 meters further down, it provided coverage over the southern slope of the mountain.

Kashiwadaniyama Fort TBD

Positioned across from Nakataniyama Fort, it supported the northern flank.

Hayashitaniyama Fort Fuwa Naomitsu

500 meters downslope from Nakataniyama, this fort formed a defensive bulwark along the Hokkoku Kaidō with an embankment over 400m long!

The string of forts that formed Shibata’s primary forward line on Mt. Gyoichi was supported by numerous smaller outposts and field fortifications scattered along the Hokkoku Kaidō. These acted as sentry points and signal posts, watching for enemy movements from the south.

Hideyoshi's Defensive Line[edit]

While Hideyoshi was engaged in Ise, he received news that Shibata had started to mobilize. Hideyoshi left Ise to Gamo Ujisato and Oda Nobukatsu and took part of his forces to Kinomoto where they arrived on March 17th. After surveying the Shibata emplacements himself and trying to lure them out, he realized this would not be a quick battle of strength. He abandoned Tenjinyama Fort which was now overshadowed by the Shibata's line on Mt. Gyoichi and established two defensive lines to bottle up Shibata and prevent him from reaching northern Omi.

Hideyoshi established his headquarters at Tagamiyama Castle, roughly 10 kilometers south of Genbao Castle, including forces assembled at nearby Kinomoto Jizoin. This became Hideyoshi's primary staging area under command of his brother, Hashiba Hidenaga.

Hideyoshi created a new forward defensive line centered on Shinmeiyama Fort with satellite fortifications on the same ridge and across the valley. Interestingly, Hideyoshi placed four former Shibata retainers - Ohgane Tohachiro, Yamaji Masakuni, and Kinoshita Kazumoto - who capitulated at Nagahama Castle to command these posts.

Shigeyama Fort

High on the mountaintop after a steep climb from Shinmeiyama Fort to prevent Shibata forces from crossing the rugged ridgeline and attacking Shinmeiyama Fort from behind.

Shinmeiyama Fort Ohgane Tohachiro and Kimura Shigekore

Anchored Hideyoshiu's forward line

Dogiyama Fort Yamaji Masakuni　and Kinoshita Kazumoto

Spearpoint of the Ridgeline facing the Hokkoku Kaido.

Tohnoyama Fort Hori Hidemasa

Intricate fort high atop the mountains on the east side of the Hokkoku Kaido, with lower satellite castles at Shobudani Fort and Mizotani Fort

Hideyoshi also constructed a large earthen embankment to physically block the road and fortify the narrow chokepoint of the Hokkoku Kaido. Orders were given not to let a single sword past this line. You may see some photos of the remains of this embankment still online today (and a marker on Google Maps), but when I first visited in 2023, it looked like it had just been leveled and no trace remained in 2025.

Hideyoshi also created a second defensive line along the mountain range on the shore of Lake Yogo from the peak of Mt. Shizugatake extending north towards the Hokkoku Kaido and linking up with his base at Tagamiyama Castle.

Shizugatake Fort Kuwayama Shigeharu

Fantastic views of nearly every fort and possible route through the mountains into northern Omi.

Oiwayama Fort Nakagawa Kiyohide

Iwasakiyama Fort Takayama Ukon

Niwa Nagahide was also provided 7,000 troops to patrol the Lake Biwa area to prevent any flanking move from the lake. With an overwhelming force and all potential lines of attack secured, Hideyoshi was prepared to wait for Shibata to make the first move.

The Battle Commences[edit]

The stalemate continued into April. On April 4 (May 8), Shibata Katsuie made the first exploratory move by launching a small attack on Shinmeiyama Fort, but Hideyoshi’s forces did not take the bait. The following day, Shibata himself departed Genbao Castle with a large force and engaged Hori Hidemasa at Tohnoyama Fort. A fierce, half-day exchange of gunfire followed, but the other units along the front line did not engage. This was likely a feint designed to prevent Hideyoshi from pulling troops away from the front.

On April 13, Yamaji Masakuni and some of his followers escaped and rejoined Sakuma Morimasa, following a failed attempt to assassinate Kimura Shigekore, the commander of the forward defensive line.

With the bulk of Hideyoshi’s army tied down at Shizugatake, Oda Nobutaka and Takigawa Kazumasa reignited their campaigns in Gifu and Ise. On April 17, Hideyoshi entrusted the Shizugatake front to Hidenaga and marched out with 20,000 troops to suppress Nobutaka at Gifu Castle.

With Hideyoshi's departure from the front lines and inside information from Yamaji about fortifications and troop placements, Sakuma Morimasa saw an opening. Shibata was cautious with the highly risky plan but eventually conceded to his nephew's strong will.

In the early hours of April 20 (May 24), Shibata led a sizeable force down the Hokkoku Kaidō to distract Hori’s men along the first defensive line between Tohnoyama Fort and Dogiyama Fort. At the same time, Sakuma Morimasa departed Gyoichiyama Fort to execute his bold mountaintop flanking strategy. Maeda Toshiie was stationed at Shigeyama to guard against any reinforcements from Shinmeiyama Fort. Following the mountain ridgeline, Sakuma circled around the west side of Lake Yogo, bypassing the more heavily defended Shizugatake Fort, and struck directly at the heart of the second defensive line at Oiwayama Fort.

After a fierce battle that saw the death of Nakagawa Kiyohide, Oiwayama Fort fell. Takayama Ukon fled to Tagamiyama Castle, and Iwasakiyama Fort fell shortly thereafter. Even the commander of Shizugatake Fort agreed to surrender at sundown.

The plan had worked better than expected. If Sakuma could hold the second defensive line, many of the troops at Shinmeiyama Fort and Dogiyama Fort — former allies from Nagahama — would likely surrender or switch sides rather than resist. That would leave only Tohnoyama and Tagamiyama forts to contend with.

Shibata’s original orders to Sakuma had been to immediately retreat after the strike on Oiwayama. His goal was to “bloody their nose” and keep Hideyoshi's troops occupied, not to win the war in a single bold maneuver. Perhaps he recalled Hideyoshi’s lightning return from the Chūgoku front less than a year earlier to defeat Akechi Mitsuhide.

But with Hideyoshi away, Sakuma grew confident. He chose to rest his troops at Oiwayama for the night, intending to move into Shizugatake Fort the next morning. Again, Shibata ordered him to withdraw — and again, Sakuma refused, convinced that it would take Hideyoshi at least three days to return from Gifu.

Unbeknownst to Sakuma, Niwa Nagahide, patrolling Lake Biwa, heard the gunfire and moved to reinforce Shizugatake Fort from the Lake Biwa side. He met up with Kuwayama as they started to abandon the castle but the two held fast instead. When Hideyoshi received word of the attack, he too acted at once. He left 5,000 troops in Gifu and led the remaining 15,000 over 50km in under six hours. The feat became legendary as the Great Minoh Return (美濃大返し).

In the early hours of April 21, Hideyoshi launched a full-scale assault with 35,000 troops. Though Sakuma’s men were isolated, exhausted, and deep in enemy territory, they fought fiercely. The battle devolved into brutal close-quarters combat. Maeda Toshiie withdrew from Shigeyama, but not to support Sakuma, he retreated toward Lake Biwa, withdrawing from the battlefield. Troops from Shinmeiyama Fort, previously trapped, now surged forward and closed in. Sakuma was surrounded on all sides. The Shibata army collapsed. Soldiers fled. Sakuma was captured and executed.

Shibata Katsuie fled to Kitanoshō Castle in defeat. Hideyoshi’s army surrounded the castle on April 23. Disobeyed, betrayed, and beaten, Shibata set fire to the castle and took his own life, along with Oichi, the sister of Nobunaga, on April 24.

Hideyoshi now controlled Echizen — and emerged as the undisputed successor to Oda Nobunaga.

Interactive Map[edit]

This map is interactive. Click the lines and flags for more details.

Loading map...

Map Legend:

Hideyoshi Forts
Katsuie Forts

Thoughts on The Battle[edit]

Looking at the map, it’s clear that Shibata Katsuie’s forces were unlikely to break through Hideyoshi’s Hokkoku Kaido defenses head-on. The forward line and secondary lines formed a formidable wall, blocking all access to northern Omi. That makes Sakuma Morimasa’s surprise attack all the more bold—and perhaps brilliant. Rather than grinding through the defenses, he descended the ridgeline directly, striking the heart of the secondary line and threatening Hideyoshi’s headquarters at Tagamiyama which Hideyoshi had depleted when he left for Gifu.

For all his tactical brilliance, Hideyoshi may have been caught off guard. Shibata’s generals were experienced in rugged, mountaintop warfare, while Hideyoshi preferred lowland sieges. If Sakuma had pressed the attack and moved into Shizugatake Fort, and Shibata had fully committed to this gambit, Maeda Toshiie might not have withdrawn. Seeing the entire secondary defensive line taken over behind their backs, the former Nagahama retainers on the forward line may well have defected turning the tide of this battle.

Legacy of the Shizugatake Castles[edit]

In Japanese, the use of fort (toride 砦) vs. castle (城) differs widely for some of these locations. There is no common rule for naming. Naming some of these locations as forts does not mean they are any less interesting nor well developed. In fact I think it's amazing how intricately they were created in such a short time. They are certainly bigger and employ more advanced techniques than some castles I have visited. The Hideyoshi forts in particular showcase many features typical of the "shokuhoukei" castles and fortifications of the period. The castles profiled here were largely abandoned following the battle. Genbao Castle, Tagamiyama Castle, and Higashinoyama Castle in particular excellently preserve the fortifications and strategy of castles at that time. They are worth visiting for any castle fans.

Field Notes[edit]

In Japanese, the use of fort (toride 砦) vs. castle (城) differs widely for some of these locations. There is no common rule for naming. Naming some of these locations as forts does not mean they are any less interesting nor well developed. In fact I think it's amazing how intricately they were created in such a short time. They are certainly bigger and employ more advanced techniques than some castles I have visited. The Hideyoshi forts in particular showcase many features typical of the "shokuhoukei" castles and fortifications of the period. The castles profiled here were largely abandoned following the battle. Genbao Castle, Tagamiyama Castle, and Higashinoyama Castle in particular excellently preserve the fortifications and strategy of castles at that time. They are worth visiting for any castle fans.

This brief article marks the culmination of six trips to the Yogo region over two years (Apr ’23–Apr ’25). For various reasons, I wasn’t able to complete them all in a single season—the weather is unpredictable, with heavy snowfalls that often linger on the mountaintops well into spring, just as they once did during the actual campaign! I was also researching as I went, adjusting plans and making exploratory forays to confirm certain sites along the way.

There are still a few places I would have liked to reach, but with enough ground covered and the key locations documented, I finally had the material needed to shape a coherent narrative. So, here we are. I will revisit the region in the future to document some of the smaller outlying forts but they are mostly one-off's that would require a full day just to reach one small site.

With a bit of hiking and light mountaineering, all the sites profiled here were fairly accessible. Trail conditions varied, but nothing was unreasonably difficult—except perhaps the steep and slippery slope from Besshōyama to Gyoichiyama, which I ultimately had to give up on. (I was also recovering from an injury and running out of time after spending too long at the lower forts!)

I loved the map signboards at many sites, all in the same distinctive style created by researcher Hiromi Hasegawa. He should really have a book of his own on the area!

Public transportation in this region is nearly non-existent. I made all these visits by renting a bicycle from either Yogo Station or Kinomoto Station. For more on access and hiking conditions, see the individual castle profiles.

With this series, more than ever, it hits home why we visit castles. You can read about battles and castles in books, you can look at maps, but nothing compares to walking the terrain, seeing what's out there and making your own conclusions. I found some texts about teh Battle of Shizugatake actually lacking. It definitely felt like the writers were just regurgitating others text and had not walked the trails, walked the castles and thought about teh implications of what they are writing about.

Bibliography[edit]

The following materials were referenced in creating the castle profiles and understanding the historical landscape for this article. Some of the assumptions above about individual castle purposes and the motivations of the key players are my own based on extensive reading and may not be explicitly stated elsewhere.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-== Shizugatake Fortification ==
-<!--
-{{#display_map:35.5135,136.2228~今市上砦;35.5148,136.2301~天神山砦;35.5112,136.2403~土器山砦;35.5105,136.2467~東野山砦;35.5080,136.2505~菖蒲谷山砦~red~0.42~10
-|layers=Esri.WorldTopoMap
-|layer=Esri.WorldTopoMap
-|geojson=Shizugatake}}
--->
-=== The Battle of Shizugatake (1583) ===
+=== Introduction ===
-The story of the Battle of Shizugatake is often oversimplified. However, the more you dig into it, the more a fascinating game of chess unfolds across the landscape of Northern Omi that would put Hashiba (Toyotomi) Hideyoshi on the path to Kanpaku.
+The story of the Battle of Shizugatake is often oversimplified. However, the more you dig into it, the more a fascinating game of chess unfolds across the landscape of Northern Omi. One that would put Hashiba (Toyotomi) Hideyoshi on the road to Kanpaku.
+''Note: Dates used below are in the old Japanese lunisolar calendar. A few modern dates have been added in parentheses at critical points for reference. This is especially important regarding the season and snowfalls for this region.''
-==== Prelude to Battle (1582–1583) ====
+=== Prelude to Battle (1582–1583) ===
-On June 27, 1582 (Tenshō 10), the Council of Kiyosu was held in Owari, where the distribution of Oda Nobunaga’s territories was decided following his death at Honnō-ji. Yet this meeting failed to stabilize the political situation—it merely ignited a new power struggle to fill the void Nobunaga left behind.
+On June 27, 1582 (Aug. 2), the Council of Kiyosu was held in Owari, where the distribution of Oda Nobunaga’s territories was decided following his death at Honnō-ji. Yet this meeting failed to stabilize the political situation—it merely ignited a new power struggle to fill the void Nobunaga left behind.
 One of the spoils of this reshuffling was [[Nagahama Castle]], originally built by Hideyoshi, it was now controlled by Shibata Katsuie who placed it under the command of his adopted son Katsutoyo. It must have pained Hideyoshi to see one of his beloved castles controlled by a rival.
@@ Line 20: / Line 14: @@
 Hideyoshi was a tactical master. While Shibata and his allies waited for spring, he seized the initiative.
-On December 2, under the cover of snowfall, Hideyoshi attacked [[Nagahama Castle]]. Katsutoyo was unable to receive reinforcements from Echizen and soon capitulated to Hideyoshi. On December 20, Hideyoshi captured Gifu Castle, forcing Oda Nobutaka to surrender. In January 1583, Takigawa Kazumasu mounted a counterattack in northern Ise against this Hideyoshi aggression. It was also quickly defeated. Towards Echizen Hideyoshi established an outpost at [[Tenjinyama Fort]] to counter Shibata's [[Genbao Castle]] with satellites at [[Chausuyama Fort]] and [[Imaichikami Fort]] to watch over the Hokkoku Kaido and to be on the lookout for any movement by Shibata.
+On December 2 (Jan. 11, 1583), under the cover of snowfall, Hideyoshi attacked [[Nagahama Castle]]. Katsutoyo was unable to receive reinforcements from Echizen and soon capitulated to Hideyoshi. On December 20, Hideyoshi captured Gifu Castle, forcing Oda Nobutaka to surrender. In January 1583, Takigawa Kazumasu mounted a counterattack in northern Ise against this Hideyoshi aggression. It was also quickly defeated. Toward Echizen, Hideyoshi established an outpost at [[Tenjinyama Fort]] to counter Shibata's [[Genbao Castle]]. It included satellite forts at [[Chausuyama Fort]] and [[Imaichikami Fort]] to monitor the Hokkoku Kaido and watch for any movement by Shibata.
-Shibata must have been chomping at the bit. He was snowed in at [[Kitanosho Castle]] and unable to open another front against Hideyoshi. Had the three parties linked up or divided Hideyoshi's attention to multiple fronts, Japanese history may have been very different.
+Shibata must have been chomping at the bit. He was snowbound in Echizen and unable to open another front against Hideyoshi. Seasonal "white demon" (白魔) snows closed the mountain passes to him. Had the three parties linked up or divided Hideyoshi's attention to multiple fronts, Japanese history may have been very different.
-==== Drawing the Battle lines ====
+=== Drawing the Battle lines ===
-One of the earliest strategic preparations was the fortification of [[Genbao Castle]], located on the border of Ōmi and Echizen Provinces. Genbao was notably well designed, suggesting that plans for its construction began immediately after the Kiyosu Council.
+One of the earliest strategic preparations was the fortification of [[Genbao Castle]], located on the border of Ōmi and Echizen Provinces. Genbao was notably well designed, suggesting that plans for its construction began soon after the Kiyosu Council.
-By late February, Shibata Katsuie made the bold decision to mobilize, despite lingering snow in the mountains. His advance force arrived at [[Genbao Castle]] on March 5th, where they began preparing it to serve as Shibata’s forward field command. When the main force followed, Sakuma Morimasa and other key generals moved to Mount Gyoichi (行市山) to establish Shibata’s primary line of defense.
+By late February (late March), Shibata Katsuie made the bold decision to mobilize, despite lingering snow in the mountains. His advance force arrived at [[Genbao Castle]] on March 5th (April 10), where they began preparing it to serve as Shibata’s forward field command. When the main force followed, Sakuma Morimasa and other key generals moved to Mount Gyoichi (行市山) to establish Shibata’s primary line of defense.
 What followed was the construction of one of the largest and most intricate networks of mountaintop forts and field fortifications seen during the Sengoku period for a single military conflict.
-'''Shibata's Forward Defensive Line'''
+====Shibata's Forward Defensive Line====
 * '''Gyoichiyama Fort''' ''Sakuma Morimasa''
-The main stronghold atop Mt. Gyoichi, connected to Genbao Castle by a rugged 3.5km ridgeline.
+A small stronghold atop Mt. Gyoichi, connected to Genbao Castle by a rugged 3.5km ridgeline.
 * [[Besshoyama Fort]] ''Maeda Toshiie''
@@ Line 41: / Line 35: @@
 * [[Tochidaniyama Fort]] ''Hara Nagayori''
-Situated 400 meters downslope from [[Besshoyama Fort]], covering mid-elevation routes.
+Situated 400 meters downslope from [[Besshoyama Fort]], acting as a central hub in this line of defense.
 * [[Nakataniyama Fort]] ''Tokuyama Hideaki'' and ''Kanamori Nagachika''
-meters further down, it provided defensive coverage over the southern slope of the mountain.
+meters further down, it provided coverage over the southern slope of the mountain.
-* [[Kashiwadani Fort]] '' TBD ''
+* [[Kashiwadaniyama Fort]] '' TBD ''
 Positioned across from ''Nakataniyama Fort'', it supported the northern flank.
 * [[Hayashitaniyama Fort]] ''Fuwa Naomitsu''
-meters downslope from Nakataniyama, this fort formed a defensive bulwark along the Hokkoku Kaidō with an embankment over 300m long!
+meters downslope from Nakataniyama, this fort formed a defensive bulwark along the Hokkoku Kaidō with an embankment over 400m long!
 The string of forts that formed Shibata’s primary forward line on Mt. Gyoichi was supported by numerous smaller outposts and field fortifications scattered along the Hokkoku Kaidō. These acted as sentry points and signal posts, watching for enemy movements from the south.
-'''Hideyoshi's Defensive Line'''
+====Hideyoshi's Defensive Line====
 While Hideyoshi was engaged in Ise, he received news that Shibata had started to mobilize. Hideyoshi left Ise to Gamo Ujisato and Oda Nobukatsu and took part of his forces to Kinomoto where they arrived on March 17th. After surveying the Shibata emplacements himself and trying to lure them out, he realized this would not be a quick battle of strength. He abandoned [[Tenjinyama Fort]] which was now overshadowed by the Shibata's line on Mt. Gyoichi and established two defensive lines to bottle up Shibata and prevent him from reaching northern Omi.
-Hideyoshi established his headquarters at [[Tagamiyama Castle]], roughly 10 kilometers south of [[Genbao Castle]], including forces assembled at nearby Kinomoto Jizoin. This became his primary staging area under command of his brother, Hashiba Hidenaga.
+Hideyoshi established his headquarters at [[Tagamiyama Castle]], roughly 10 kilometers south of [[Genbao Castle]], including forces assembled at nearby Kinomoto Jizoin. This became Hideyoshi's primary staging area under command of his brother, Hashiba Hidenaga.
+Hideyoshi created a new forward defensive line centered on [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] with satellite fortifications on the same ridge and across the valley. Interestingly, Hideyoshi placed four former Shibata retainers - Ohgane Tohachiro, Yamaji Masakuni, and Kinoshita Kazumoto - who capitulated at [[Nagahama Castle]] to command these posts.
+* '''Shigeyama Fort'''
+High on the mountaintop after a steep climb from [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] to prevent Shibata forces from crossing the rugged ridgeline and attacking [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] from behind.
+* [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] ''Ohgane Tohachiro and Kimura Shigekore''
+Anchored Hideyoshiu's forward line
+* [[Dogiyama Fort]] ''Yamaji Masakuni　and Kinoshita Kazumoto''
+Spearpoint of the Ridgeline facing the Hokkoku Kaido.
-Hideyoshi created his new forward defensive line centered on [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] with satellite fortifications on the same ridge line and across the valley.
+* [[Tohnoyama Fort]] ''Hori Hidemasa''
+Intricate fort high atop the mountains on the east side of the Hokkoku Kaido, with lower satellite castles at [[Shobudani Fort]] and [[Mizotani Fort]]
-'''Shigeyama Fort'''
+Hideyoshi also constructed a large earthen embankment to physically block the road and fortify the narrow chokepoint of the Hokkoku Kaido. Orders were given not to let a single sword past this line. You may see some photos of the remains of this embankment still online today (and a marker on Google Maps), but when I first visited in 2023, it looked like it had just been leveled and no trace remained in 2025.
-High on the mountaintop after a steep climb from [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] to prevent Shibata forces from crossing the rugged ridgeline and attacking [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] form behind.
-[[Shinmeiyama Fort]]
+Hideyoshi also created a second defensive line along the mountain range on the shore of Lake Yogo from the peak of Mt. Shizugatake extending north towards the Hokkoku Kaido and linking up with his base at [[Tagamiyama Castle]].
-[[Dogiyama Fort]]
+* [[Shizugatake Fort]] ''Kuwayama Shigeharu''
+Fantastic views of nearly every fort and possible route through the mountains into northern Omi.
-[[Higashinoyama Fort]] (also called Tonoyama Fort)
+* [[Oiwayama Fort]] ''Nakagawa Kiyohide''
-[[Shobudani Fort]]
+* [[Iwasakiyama Fort]] ''Takayama Ukon''
-[[Mizotani Fort]]
+Niwa Nagahide was also provided 7,000 troops to patrol the Lake Biwa area to prevent any flanking move from the lake. With an overwhelming force and all potential lines of attack secured, Hideyoshi was prepared to wait for Shibata to make the first move.
-Hideyoshi constructed a large earthen embankment to physically block the road and fortify the narrow chokepoint of the Hokoku Kaido with orders were given to not let a single sword past this line. You may see some photos of the remains of this online still today near the foot [[Shobudani Fort]], but when I first visited in 2023, it looked like it had just been leveled.
+=== The Battle Commences ===
-Hideyoshi's second defensive line was built along the mountain range on the shore of Lake Yogo from the peak of Mt. Shizugatake extending north towards the Hokkoku Kaido and linking up with his base at [[Tagamiyama Castle]]
+The stalemate continued into April. On April 4 (May 8), Shibata Katsuie made the first exploratory move by launching a small attack on [[Shinmeiyama Fort]], but Hideyoshi’s forces did not take the bait. The following day, Shibata himself departed [[Genbao Castle]] with a large force and engaged Hori Hidemasa at [[Tohnoyama Fort]]. A fierce, half-day exchange of gunfire followed, but the other units along the front line did not engage. This was likely a feint designed to prevent Hideyoshi from pulling troops away from the front.
-[[Shizugatake Fort]]
+On April 13, Yamaji Masakuni and some of his followers escaped and rejoined Sakuma Morimasa, following a failed attempt to assassinate Kimura Shigekore, the commander of the forward defensive line.
-[[Oiwayama Fort]]
+With the bulk of Hideyoshi’s army tied down at Shizugatake, Oda Nobutaka and Takigawa Kazumasa reignited their campaigns in Gifu and Ise. On April 17, Hideyoshi entrusted the Shizugatake front to Hidenaga and marched out with 20,000 troops to suppress Nobutaka at [[Gifu Castle]].
-[[Iwasakiyama Fort]]
+With Hideyoshi's departure from the front lines and inside information from Yamaji about fortifications and troop placements, Sakuma Morimasa saw an opening. Shibata was cautious with the highly risky plan but eventually conceded to his nephew's strong will.
+In the early hours of April 20 (May 24), Shibata led a sizeable force down the Hokkoku Kaidō to distract Hori’s men along the first defensive line between [[Tohnoyama Fort]] and [[Dogiyama Fort]]. At the same time, Sakuma Morimasa departed [[Gyoichiyama Fort]] to execute his bold mountaintop flanking strategy. Maeda Toshiie was stationed at Shigeyama to guard against any reinforcements from [[Shinmeiyama Fort]]. Following the mountain ridgeline, Sakuma circled around the west side of Lake Yogo, bypassing the more heavily defended [[Shizugatake Fort]], and struck directly at the heart of the second defensive line at [[Oiwayama Fort]].
-===  The Battle Commences (April 19, 1583) ===
+After a fierce battle that saw the death of Nakagawa Kiyohide, [[Oiwayama Fort]] fell. Takayama Ukon fled to [[Tagamiyama Castle]], and [[Iwasakiyama Fort]] fell shortly thereafter. Even the commander of [[Shizugatake Fort]] agreed to surrender at sundown.
-In mid-April, Hideyoshi had shifted east to confront Nobutaka (who, despite surrendering earlier, had allied with Takigawa Kazumasa). With Hideyoshi absent, Sakuma Morimasa, Katsuie’s nephew, saw an opening.
+The plan had worked better than expected. If Sakuma could hold the second defensive line, many of the troops at [[Shinmeiyama Fort]] and [[Dogiyama Fort]] — former allies from Nagahama — would likely surrender or switch sides rather than resist. That would leave only [[Tohnoyama Fort|Tohnoyama]] and [[Tagamiyama Castle|Tagamiyama]] forts to contend with.
-On April 19, Morimasa launched a surprise assault on Mt. Shizugatake:
+Shibata’s original orders to Sakuma had been to immediately retreat after the strike on Oiwayama. His goal was to “bloody their nose” and keep Hideyoshi's troops occupied, not to win the war in a single bold maneuver. Perhaps he recalled Hideyoshi’s lightning return from the Chūgoku front less than a year earlier to defeat Akechi Mitsuhide.
-- Ōiwa Fort, held by Nakagawa Kiyohide, fell quickly; Kiyohide was killed.
+But with Hideyoshi away, Sakuma grew confident. He chose to rest his troops at Oiwayama for the night, intending to move into [[Shizugatake Fort]] the next morning. Again, Shibata ordered him to withdraw — and again, Sakuma refused, convinced that it would take Hideyoshi at least three days to return from Gifu.
-- Iwasaki Fort, held by Takayama Ukon, was also lost under pressure.
-- Morimasa then laid siege to Shizugatake itself.
-Despite Katsuie’s orders to retreat and consolidate, Morimasa refused. He believed Hideyoshi would need three days to return from Gifu, giving him time to capture Shizugatake without further risk.
+Unbeknownst to Sakuma, Niwa Nagahide, patrolling Lake Biwa, heard the gunfire and moved to reinforce [[Shizugatake Fort]] from the Lake Biwa side. He met up with Kuwayama as they started to abandon the castle but the two held fast instead. When Hideyoshi received word of the attack, he too acted at once. He left 5,000 troops in Gifu and led the remaining 15,000 over 50km in under six hours. The feat became legendary as the Great Minoh Return (美濃大返し).
-But on April 20, Hideyoshi received news of the attack—and moved immediately. That night, thousands of torches lit up the base of the mountain. Hideyoshi’s army had marched over 50km in under six hours. The feat became legendary as the Great Minoh Return (美濃大返し).
+In the early hours of April 21, Hideyoshi launched a full-scale assault with 35,000 troops. Though Sakuma’s men were isolated, exhausted, and deep in enemy territory, they fought fiercely. The battle devolved into brutal close-quarters combat. Maeda Toshiie withdrew from Shigeyama, but not to support Sakuma, he retreated toward Lake Biwa, withdrawing from the battlefield. Troops from [[Shinmeiyama Fort]], previously trapped, now surged forward and closed in. Sakuma was surrounded on all sides. The Shibata army collapsed. Soldiers fled. Sakuma was captured and executed.
-At dawn on April 21, Hideyoshi launched a full assault. Despite being isolated deep in enemy territory, Sakuma’s army resisted fiercely, and the battle dissolved into intense close-quarters fighting. Seeing Hideyoshi shift his attack toward Shibata Katsumasa, Sakuma attempted to pursue—escalating the chaos. Then, crucially, Maeda Toshiie’s forces began to withdraw, creating panic across the Shibata lines.
+Shibata Katsuie fled to [[Kitanoshō Castle]] in defeat. Hideyoshi’s army surrounded the castle on April 23. Disobeyed, betrayed, and beaten, Shibata set fire to the castle and took his own life, along with Oichi, the sister of Nobunaga, on April 24.
-Hideyoshi seized the opportunity. The Shibata army collapsed. Soldiers fled, abandoning weapons and armor. Sakuma Morimasa was captured and executed. Back at Kitanosho, Shibata Katsuie—betrayed, defeated, and cornered—set fire to his castle and committed suicide alongside Oichi, Nobunaga’s sister.
+Hideyoshi now controlled Echizen — and emerged as the undisputed successor to Oda Nobunaga.
+=== Interactive Map ===
 This map is interactive. Click the lines and flags for more details.
@@ Line 111: / Line 117: @@
 .52077,136.20507~[[Oiwayama Fort]]~Manned by Nakagawa Kiyohide. Fell to Sakumra Apr.20~Redflag35.png;
 .53054,136.20442~Iwasakiyama Fort~Manned by Takayama Ukon. Fella t the same time as Oiwayama~Redflag35.png;
-.51459,136.22458~Tagamiyama Castle~text~Redflag35.png~30;
+.51459,136.22458~Tagamiyama Castle~text~Redflag35.png;
+.50161,136.2364~Tabeyama Castle~text~Redflag35.png;
 .55708,136.1919~Chausuyama Fort~text~Redflag35.png;
 .56176,136.20525~Imaichikami Fort~text~Redflag35.png;
 .55479,136.18958~Tenjinyama Fort~text~Redflag35.png;
 .59783,136.17662~Genbao Castle~text~Blueflag35.png;
-.56815, 136.1901~Hayashitaniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.56815,136.1901~Hayashitaniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
-.56536, 136.18661~Nakataniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png
+.56536,136.18661~Nakataniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.56754,136.18421~Tochidaniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.56887,136.18638~Kashiwadaniyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.56369,136.18172~Besshoyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.56827,136.16945~Gyoichiyama Fort~text~Blueflag35.png;
+.53614,136.18418~Shigeyama~text~Redflag35.png;
+.53864,136.19111~Shinmei~text~Redflag35.png;
+.54415,136.19834~Dogiyama~text~Redflag35.png;
+.55581,136.20936~Higashinoyama~text~Redflag35.png;
+.55292,136.20586~Shobudani~text~Redflag35.png;
+.54935, 136.20612~Mizotani~text~Redflag35.png;
 |service=leaflet
 |autozoom=1
@@ Line 127: / Line 144: @@
 |lines=
 .50608,136.1931:35.52077,136.20507:35.53054,136.20442~Second Defensive Line~some mor text~red~0.75~3;
-.51459,136.22458:35.52077,136.20507~Second Defensive Line~I am a text~#b51a00~0.5~1;
+.50161,136.2364:35.51459,136.22458:35.52077,136.20507~Second Defensive Line~I am a text~#b51a00~0.75~3;
 .55479,136.18958:35.55708,136.1919:35.56176,136.20525~Original Forward Defensive Line~some mor text~red~0.75~3;
-.56815, 136.1901:35.56536,136.18661~Mt Gyoichi Forward Line~text~blue~0.75~3;
+.56815,136.1901:35.56536,136.18661:35.56754,136.18421:35.56369,136.18172:35.5635186,136.1784657:35.56827, 136.16945~Mt Gyoichi Forward Line~text~blue~0.75~3;
+.56754,136.18421:35.56887,136.18638~Mt Gyoichi Forward Line~text~blue~0.75~3;
+.53614,136.18418:35.53864,136.19111:35.54415,136.19834:35.55292,136.20586:35.55581,136.20936~New Forward Defensive Line~some mor text~red~0.75~3;
 }}
@@ Line 135: / Line 154: @@
 * [[File:Redflag35.png|30px]] Hideyoshi Forts
 * [[File:Blueflag35.png|30px]] Katsuie Forts
+=== Thoughts on The Battle ===
+Looking at the map, it’s clear that Shibata Katsuie’s forces were unlikely to break through Hideyoshi’s Hokkoku Kaido defenses head-on. The forward line and secondary lines formed a formidable wall, blocking all access to northern Omi. That makes Sakuma Morimasa’s surprise attack all the more bold—and perhaps brilliant. Rather than grinding through the defenses, he descended the ridgeline directly, striking the heart of the secondary line and threatening Hideyoshi’s headquarters at [[Tagamiyama Fort|Tagamiyama]] which Hideyoshi had depleted when he left for Gifu.
+For all his tactical brilliance, Hideyoshi may have been caught off guard. Shibata’s generals were experienced in rugged, mountaintop warfare, while Hideyoshi preferred lowland sieges. If Sakuma had pressed the attack and moved into [[Shizugatake Fort]], and Shibata had fully committed to this gambit, Maeda Toshiie might not have withdrawn. Seeing the entire secondary defensive line taken over behind their backs, the former Nagahama retainers on the forward line may well have defected turning the tide of this battle.
 === Legacy of the Shizugatake Castles ===
@@ Line 140: / Line 164: @@
 In Japanese, the use of fort (toride 砦) vs. castle (城) differs widely for some of these locations. There is no common rule for naming. Naming some of these locations as ''forts'' does not mean they are any less interesting nor well developed. In fact I think it's amazing how intricately they were created in such a short time. They are certainly bigger and employ more advanced techniques than some castles I have visited. The Hideyoshi forts in particular showcase many features typical of the "shokuhoukei" castles and fortifications of the period. The castles profiled here were largely abandoned following the battle. Genbao Castle, Tagamiyama Castle, and Higashinoyama Castle in particular excellently preserve the fortifications and strategy of castles at that time. They are worth visiting for any castle fans.
-Apart from Genbao Castle, there are some significant differences between the Shibata fortifications and those of Hideyoshi which may be traced to their purpose as well. The Shibata positions formed a simple battle line and often lack the complex defensive. They served to fortify key positions of troops looking to break through the Hideyoshi blockade and reach into Northern Omi to further attack Hideyoshi. Hideyoshi on the other hand only had to bottle up the Shibata forces and prevent them getting through. They were prepared for an extended siege and had two full defensive lines to prevent Shibata's incursion. Hideyoshi's allies could defend their positions for the long term which is why we see much more intricate castle structures and satellite forts.
+=== Field Notes ===
+In Japanese, the use of fort (toride 砦) vs. castle (城) differs widely for some of these locations. There is no common rule for naming. Naming some of these locations as ''forts'' does not mean they are any less interesting nor well developed. In fact I think it's amazing how intricately they were created in such a short time. They are certainly bigger and employ more advanced techniques than some castles I have visited. The Hideyoshi forts in particular showcase many features typical of the "shokuhoukei" castles and fortifications of the period. The castles profiled here were largely abandoned following the battle. Genbao Castle, Tagamiyama Castle, and Higashinoyama Castle in particular excellently preserve the fortifications and strategy of castles at that time. They are worth visiting for any castle fans.
+This brief article marks the culmination of six trips to the Yogo region over two years (Apr ’23–Apr ’25). For various reasons, I wasn’t able to complete them all in a single season—the weather is unpredictable, with heavy snowfalls that often linger on the mountaintops well into spring, just as they once did during the actual campaign! I was also researching as I went, adjusting plans and making exploratory forays to confirm certain sites along the way.
-(1) While some may argue that the Battle of Komaki Nagakute was more important: it was longer, bigger and pitted Hideyoshi against the eventual Shogun Tokugawa Ieyasu, I think the Battle of Shizugatake was more critical to Hideyoshi. It established him as the pre-eminent military general in the post-Oda power vacuum. It was a decisive victory against the strongest military rival at the time and won him allies like Maeda Toshiie who tipped the scales of military and political power towards Hideyoshi. The Battle of Komaki Nagakute essentially ended in stalemate. Ieyasu won a tactical victory but an uneasy peace was eventually negotiated and Ieyasu retained his lands and titles in a cold alliance until Hideyoshi could push him out to Edo following the Siege of Odawara (1590).
-=== Field Notes ===
-This brief article marks the culmination of six trips to the Yogo region over two years (Apr ’23–Apr ’25). For various reasons, I wasn’t able to complete them all in a single season—the weather is unpredictable, with heavy snowfalls that often linger on the mountaintops well into spring, just as they once did during the actual campaigns! I was also researching as I went, adjusting plans and making exploratory forays to confirm certain sites along the way.
 There are still a few places I would have liked to reach, but with enough ground covered and the key locations documented, I finally had the material needed to shape a coherent narrative. So, here we are. I will revisit the region in the future to document some of the smaller outlying forts but they are mostly one-off's that would require a full day just to reach one small site.
@@ Line 158: / Line 177: @@
 Public transportation in this region is nearly non-existent. I made all these visits by renting a bicycle from either Yogo Station or Kinomoto Station. For more on access and hiking conditions, see the individual castle profiles.
 With this series, more than ever, it hits home why we visit castles. You can read about battles and castles in books, you can look at maps, but nothing compares to walking the terrain, seeing what's out there and making your own conclusions. I found some texts about teh Battle of Shizugatake actually lacking. It definitely felt like the writers were just regurgitating others text and had not walked the trails, walked the castles and thought about teh implications of what they are writing about.
-==== Bibliography ====
+=== Bibliography ===
 The following materials were referenced in creating the castle profiles and understanding the historical landscape for this article. Some of the assumptions above about individual castle purposes and the motivations of the key players are my own based on extensive reading and may not be explicitly stated elsewhere.